A leaked WhatsApp message has sparked a wave of criticism online over the status of the separation of powers in Spain and the quality of its democracy.
Last week, PP and PSOE reached an agreement over the new members and chair of the General Council of the Judiciary (CGPJ) and the Supreme Court. Today, a WhatsApp message was reported by El Español, sent by PP's spokesperson in the Senate, Ignacio Cosidó, over the weekend, boasting of it as a "stupendous move".
Les típiques coses que defineixen una "democràcia exemplar" https://t.co/tuK3iqbW6a
— Carles Puigdemont (@KRLS) 19 de novembre de 2018
Quoted tweet from lawyer Gonzalo Boye: These messages reveal, among other things, that: 1. They've got a goal past Pedro Sánchez, 2. The CGPJ and the Supreme Court respond to political interests, and 3. Marchena is PP's man for the control of the Supreme Court and the justice system.
Comment from president in exile Carles Puigdemont: The typical things which define an "exemplary democracy".
Quan apel·len a la separació de poders per dir que no poden acabar amb la repressió es refereixen a això? https://t.co/SuE6ZpRD2O
— Roger Torrent 🎗 (@rogertorrent) 19 de novembre de 2018
Speaker of the Catalan Parliament Roger Torrent: When they call on the separation of powers to say they cannot end with the repression are they referring to that?
El portaveu del PP al Senat es vanta de controlar el tribunal que jutjarà els encausats per l’1-O:”Controlaremos la Sala Segunda desde detrás"
— Pere Aragonès 🎗 (@perearagones) 19 de novembre de 2018
Posa paraules al que ja sabíem: que la divisió de poders a Espanya és un miratge. https://t.co/AlaHK7cWt8
Deputy Catalan president Pere Aragonès: The PP's spokesperson in the Senate boasts about controling the court which will try those charged over the 1st October [referendum]: "We'll control the Second Chamber from behind the scenes". It puts words to what we already knew: that the separation of powers in Spain is a mirage.
Independencia judicial y separación de poderes...
— Jon Inarritu (@JonInarritu) 19 de novembre de 2018
“Controlaremos la Sala Segunda desde detrás": el 'whatsapp' de Cosidó justificando el pacto con el PSOE en el CGPJ https://t.co/UcCrnqBR6G
Senator Jon Inarritu (EH Bildu): Judicial independence and separation of powers... "We'll control the Second Chamber from behind the scenes": Cosidó's WhatsApp justifying the pact with PSOE for the CGPJ.
"Controlaremos la Sala Segunda desde detrás", “ponemos un Presidente [del CGPJ] excepcional”. Comentaris que demostren la independència judicial, separació de poders, la imparcialitat de la justícia i tal... https://t.co/1aLJV1Y6El
— Marcel Mauri 🎗 (@marcelmauri) 19 de novembre de 2018
Deputy president of Òmnium Cultural, Marcel Mauri: Comments which demonstrate judicial independence, the separation of powers, the impartiality of justice and such...
Escandaloso !
— J. Alonso-Cuevillas (@JaumeAlonsoCuev) 19 de novembre de 2018
Controlar los tribunales en beneficio propio no es propio de regímenes democráticos
"Controlaremos la Sala Segunda desde detrás": el 'whatsapp' de Cosidó justificando el pacto con el PSOE en el CGPJ https://t.co/zaX9L33JL3
Lawyer Jaume Alonso-Cuevillas: Scandalous! Controlling the courts for your own benefit isn't appropriate for a democratic regime.
"Controlaremos la Sala Segunda desde detrás": el 'whatsapp' de Cosidó justificando el pacto con el PSOE en el CGPJ https://t.co/UvFMYCEoeL.
— Joan Queralt (@JoanQueralt) 19 de novembre de 2018
Así se fabrica una justicia independiente y ajena a la interferencia partidista.
Otro ejemplo más de la Arcadia de la Desfachatez
Law professor Joan Queralt: That's how you construct an independent justice system free of partisan interference. Yet another example of the Arcadia of Chutzpah.
PP speaker at Spanish Senate justifying the pact PP-PSOE:
— Meritxell Serret (@MeritxellSerret) 19 de novembre de 2018
“Renewal of 2/3 of the Supreme Court and hundreds of appointments in the judiciary were at stake, vital for the PP and for the future of #Spain.
We’ll control 2nd Room from behind"#Shame#RuleofLawhttps://t.co/i9w6Z40ahJ
Minister in exile Meritxell Serret.
"Controlaremos la Sala Segunda desde detrás". Así defiende el portavoz del PP el vergonzoso pacto cerrado con PSOE-Podemos para repartirse a los jueces. Presumiendo con descaro de su mangoneo y de la pinza Sánchez-Casado contra una Justicia independiente. https://t.co/mlKgsTl1Et
— Albert Rivera (@Albert_Rivera) November 19, 2018
Cs' leader Albert Rivera: "We'll control the Second Chamber from behind the scenes". That's how the PP's spokesperson defends the shameful pact reached with PSOE-Podemos to share out the judges. Impertinently bragging about their meddling and the Sánchez-Casado pincer against an independent.