British international law specialist Ben Emmerson, the barrister who took the case of Catalan political prisoners Oriol Junqueras, Jordi Sànchez and Jordi Cuixart to the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (WGAD), has raised the tone of his criticisms against the Spanish government's positioning on the issue this Saturday, categorically denying the claims made by Spanish officials and saying that the country was acting like a "rogue state". This follows the Spanish call for the recusal of two members of the UN Working Group which had found the prisoners to have been kept in custody arbitrarily.
In a tweet thread, Emmerson asserted that "the Spanish Government’s response to the WGAD ruling is looking increasingly desperate", while denying that there was any "conflict of interest" or that the report was leaked to Emmerson in advance. "There is no truth whatsoever in either of these claims," said the barrister, who furthermore says he "has never met (or spoken to) any of the current members of WGAD."
The Spanish Government’s response to the WGAD ruling is looking increasingly desperate. Now they are complaining about an alleged conflict of interest, and alleging that the decision was leaked to me in advance. There is no truth whatsoever in either of these claims. 1/3
— Ben Emmerson 🎗️ (@BenEmmerson1) 1 de junio de 2019
I have never met (or spoken) to any of the current members of WGAD. Two of them were formerly UN Special Rapporteurs at the same time as I was. Our staff members collaborated on joint letters, but I never dealt directly with either of them. There is no conflict of interest. 2/3
— Ben Emmerson 🎗️ (@BenEmmerson1) 1 de junio de 2019
In addition, he noted that Spanish officials "have deliberately lied to the UN" and pointed to them as the people responsible for a leak of the report to the newspaper El País, the first to give details of the text. He asserted that all of this will be clarified when the UN "investigates these bogus complaints," because "this level of deliberate dishonesty from the officials of a UN Member State is rare. Spain is acting like a rogue State. By making these desperate allegations, Sanchez has shot himself in the foot."
Nor did anyone on the WGAD or it’s Secretariat leak the decision in advance. The Government deliberately leaked it, as the cover letter makes clear. This was a dishonest attempt to smear the WGAD by the Government of Pedro Sanchez. #ShameOnSpain
— Ben Emmerson 🎗️ (@BenEmmerson1) 1 de junio de 2019
Ad hominem attacks like this are the last refuge of a desperate government. The officials working for Sanchez have deliberately lied to the UN, claiming the decision was leaked to me in advance, when they knew full well that they leaked it themselves to El Pais. They set this up.
— Ben Emmerson 🎗️ (@BenEmmerson1) 1 de junio de 2019
It will all become clear when these bogus complaints are investigated by the UN. This level of deliberate dishonesty from the officials of a UN Member State is rare. Spain is acting like a rogue State. By making these desperate allegations, Sanchez has shot himself in the foot.
— Ben Emmerson 🎗️ (@BenEmmerson1) 1 de junio de 2019
Finally, in a referrence to the Supreme Court trial of Junqueras, Sànchez and Cuixart and nine other pro-independence leaders, the lawyer called on the Spanish PM to "stop this Stalinist show trial" and ended with a football metaphor.
Sanchez would do better to show some political judgment and maturity. He needs to accept the verdict of the WGAD, and stop this Stalinist show trial now. And Pedro, remember the reason Barcelona is so great at football: “Play the ball, not the man”.
— Ben Emmerson 🎗️ (@BenEmmerson1) 1 de junio de 2019